Why is the United States poised to try Jose Padilla as a dangerous terrorist, long after it has become perfectly clear that he was just the wrong Muslim in the wrong airport on the wrong day? Why is the United States still holding hundreds of detainees at Guantanamo Bay, long after years of interrogation and abuse have established that few, if any, of them are the deadly terrorists they have been held out to be? And why is President Bush still issuing grandiose and provocative signing statements, the latest of which claims that the executive branch holds the power to open mail as it sees fit? Willing to give the benefit of the doubt, I once believed the common thread here was presidential blindness-an extreme executive-branch myopia that leads the president to believe that these futile little measures are somehow integral to combating terrorism. That this is some piece of self-delusion that precludes Bush and his advisers from recognizing that Padilla is just a chump and Guantanamo merely a holding pen for a jumble of innocent and half-guilty wretches. But it has finally become clear that the goal of these foolish efforts isn’t really to win […]
Sunday, January 21st, 2007
Absolute Power: The Real Reason the Bush Administration Won’t Back Down on Guantanamo
Author: DAHLIA LITHWICK
Source: Slate.com
Publication Date: Saturday, Jan. 13, 2007, at 6:52 AM ET
Link: Absolute Power: The Real Reason the Bush Administration Won’t Back Down on Guantanamo
Source: Slate.com
Publication Date: Saturday, Jan. 13, 2007, at 6:52 AM ET
Link: Absolute Power: The Real Reason the Bush Administration Won’t Back Down on Guantanamo
Stephan: This is more polemic than I like for SR, but the argument it makes is one that I have not only thought of myself, but heard put forward several times while I was in Europe. What disturbs me as much as anything else is that we are thinking about this, and having this as part of our public conversation at all.