President Nasser, who has a taste for anniversaries, was expected to celebrate one at Gaza last weekend. It is exactly a year since the Israelis left the strip, and prophets had whispered that he might declare a Palestinian republic there. Instead he made only a weak gesture; perhaps he is not sufficiently sure of his strength in the refugee areas not under his control to claim the allegiance of Palestinians everywhere. He gave Gaza a legislative council dominated by Egyptians and Egyptian-appointed members, and an executive council appointed by the Egyptian minister. This is far short of the independent status he might have used to rally all dispersed Palestinians. What held him back? Even within the narrow confines of the Gaza strip, he has to contend with a struggle between the indigenous land-owning families and the refugees. The Gaza families have a way of keeping on both sides of the fence, and the refugees have produced no real leaders. The former Mufti of Jerusalem can no longer be dusted down and brought forward as the leader of all Palestinians; he is now heard from only when it suits his Egyptian hosts. He has recently said that his ‘All Palestine […]
Wednesday, January 14th, 2009
Too Late for Palestine?
Stephan: After I published my short essay on what I would do if I were a Palestinian, several readers on the left wrote me to tell me I was being simplistic, and to rail against the Israelis. This entirely missed my point - I am not an apologist for the Israelis. I was proposing that only a new approach was going to break the cycle, and that an historically proven option can be found in the Strategy of Beingness (search the SR archives for my essay the Beingness Doctrine). From the Beingness perspective the real power lies with the Palestinians, if they would but use it.
In the course of these complaints they also revealed a sad lack of understanding of the history of this terrible, bloody, painful issue.
To try to give some sense of historical context, I located this article from half a century ago that appeared in the March 22nd 1958 issue of the Economist. It describes an aspect of this issue that is now largely forgotten - the role of the Arab nations in the Palestinian's quest for a state - which is a significant factor in the worldline of this issue.