Wednesday, April 13th, 2016
Stephan: The Theocratic Right's misty eyed vision of marriage being only between one man and one woman, a dominate husband, and a submissive wife is pure fantasy as anyone who reads either fiction or non-fiction about past societies knows. Historically marriage has been a contract made for many reasons, frequently the participants having no choice in the matter, and frequently involving multiple partners. The Biblical arguments against marriage equality have no substance either Biblically -- many marriages in the Bible are plural -- or secularly, as this article lays out.
We need to stop torturing the lives of decent people by making social policy on the basis of hate and discomfort with something unfamiliar. The function of the state is to produce wellness; stable relationships based on love, particularly if they nurture children do that regardless of gender, and should be encouraged.
Draupadi, a princess and queen in the Indian epic Mahābhārata, with her five husbands (the Pandavas)
The following is an adapted excerpt from the updated edition of The Way We Never Were by Stephanie Coontz (Basic Books, 2016):
There is a tendency for many Americans to view present-day family and gender relations through the foggy lens of nostalgia for a mostly mythical past.
Nostalgia is a very human trait. When school children returning from summer vacation are asked to name good and bad things about their summer, the lists tend to be equally long. As the year goes on, however, if the exercise is repeated, the good list grows longer and the bad list gets shorter, until by the end of the year the children are describing not their actual vacations but their idealized image of “vacation.”
So it is with our collective “memory” of family life. As time passes, the actual complexity of our history—even of our own personal experience—gets buried under the […]