Stephan: It is an article of faith to the NRA and gun proponents, that more guns make things safer. There is not a shred of evidence that this is true, and an already large, and still growing, corpus of research saying it is pernicious nonsense. Perhaps the most egregious manifestation of this zombie thinking is the scheme to arm teachers.
There are so many wrong things about this idea it is hard to know where to start.
Anyone who knows anything about combat knows that if one soldier only has a handgun, let's say your standard .45, and the other solider has an AK-47 or AR-15 rifle that the odds are overwhelming the rifle wielding soldier will win the day.
The idea that a kindergarten teacher, or a sophomore algebra teacher is going to run out into a hallway packed with screaming frightened children running away from a killer, who is pumping out possibly hundreds of rounds, and pick the killer off as happens in movies is absolute nonsense. If you hear someone say we should arm teachers so that they can deter shooters, you know you are listening to a gun zombie.
In a highly emotional adrenaline driven state it is very hard even for trained soldiers who are in their first combat engagements to hit anything. Why do you think when the police get into gun confrontations, even when the person they are firing on has no gun, that they fire so many rounds and that most splatter all over the scene, frequently hurting people who are just innocent bystanders? And these are trained police.
It is all is just so much crap being put forward by the NRA and its dimwitted followers. And then there is this.
Credit: Daily Beast
President Trump’s proposal to arm teachers seemed nutty enough even before a second former high school teacher of the year was arrested for firing a gun inside his school.
Both teachers were in Georgia, which generally prohibits people from carrying firearms on school grounds, The first was a star math instructor at Lithia Springs High School, 25 miles from Atlanta. He fired one bullet from a handgun in what may have been a suicide attempt back in August.
The second was on Wednesday, when a star social studies teacher at Dalton High School, 90 miles from Atlanta. He was arrested for barricading himself in his classroom and firing a shot with a handgun for reasons yet to be determined.
In between the two teacher-involved incidents, the mass shooting at a Florida high school prompted President Trump to propose arming educators:
“Armed Educators (and trusted people who work within a school) love our students and will protect them. Very smart people. Must be firearms adept & have annual training. Should get yearly […]
The link to the full article has been updated.
The teachers I had in high school would use a board to whack our butts after we did something to make them mad. I can imagine a teacher shooting a student if he got fed up with the student’s misdeeds like not shutting up during class or whatever makes the teacher mad. Teaching is hard, and some teachers internalize their hatred which can come out some days in a very bad way. I even had a teacher punching me in the face because I was talking during a lecture; luckily I had a friend who came to my rescue and grabbed the teacher from behind to stop him or he would have continued beating me up. I can imagine what would a stressed out teacher would do if he had a gun, and it might lead to a teacher shooting a student.
Trump’s idea is really stupid. He does not know the psychological implications of teachers having guns.