Stephan: If you read me regularly you know I have been talking about what I call the Great Schism Trend for over a decade, (see SR archives). This idea is beginning to gain greater currency amongst political commentators because it has become so obvious. Here is an example of what I mean. My prediction is that we will remain one country, but that power will devolve down to the states. That's what the Republican governed Red states want, but I don't think they realize where that leads because the Red states always have inferior governance and a lower level of social wellbeing, and could not function without the funding they get from the Blue states. As this schism goes on Blue states are going to get tired of underwriting the failure of the Red states which, I think, is going to lead to a restructuring of the senate, and the elimination of the electoral college, leaving the Red states to increasingly fend for themselves. That, in turn, is going to lead to people, particularly well-educated people and women, moving out of Red states. So I take this article as a tell that the Great Schism Trend is gathering momentum.
Among the Editorial Board’s myriad mandates, as I see them, is bursting dogma, flaying stigma, and otherwise defenestrating ideas that make cohering American politics harder than necessary.
For instance: The United States is one country.
Nope.
That we are not one country is evident to anyone who has traveled widely around the country, who has lived and worked in various parts of the country or who has bothered to learn the country’s history.
Indeed, we are held together loosely by a constitution, but our founding document has been used to sow division as much as, or more than, to cement unity. Meanwhile, there isn’t really an America so much Americas that pretend to be more in line than they are. They pretend because those Americas might be different if they stopped.
Real sovereign units, made-up bigger one
That we are not one country is evidenced also by the early party primary states. Iowa (first) is different from New Hampshire (second), which are different from South Carolina (third) and Nevada (fourth).
Sure, voters there call themselves Democrats, but they are so distinct by geography, culture […]
Social wellbeing should be a RIGHT for all human beings, as well as animals.